Jews Unable to Understand Anti-Semitism (Updated)
September 14, 2013
It would be easier to teach a wolf to sympathize with his prey, than expect Jews like Goldhagen to understand anti-Semitism. Cabalist Judaism is satanic. The cause of anti Semitism is the age-old Cabalist mission to dominate and enslave mankind.
The New World Order essentially is an Illuminati Jewish solipsism by definition dependent on suppressing and inverting Truth. Ordinary Jews are the first to be deceived.
In the WSJ review excerpted below, elite Jewish lawyer Anthony Julius writes, regretfully,
"The Devil That Never Dies" is "so easily and justly dismissible," it weakens the Jewish cause.
Michael Hoffman Unable to Understand Protocols of Zion
(Michael Hoffman, left, is the world's leading authority on Judaism)
Below that, I post Michael Hoffman's comment on Goldhagen's book but take him to task for dismissing the Protocols of Zion as "cartoonish" and "lurid, probably faked." This is an astonishing lapse by Hoffman who seems to think that the Protocols are a clever ruse to distract us from the evils of the Talmud, as if the two were incompatible.
There is nothing "cartoonish," "lurid" or "faked" about the Protocols. If there were, the Illuminati would not have stigmatized them in the West or made possession punishable by death in the USSR. They are a revelation of the true nature of our world and it is disturbing to see Michael Hoffman disparage them.
By Anthony Julius
(Book Review abridged by henrymakow.com)
Daniel Jonah Goldhagen, left, wants us to believe that anti-Semitism is the devil as the devil is envisioned by revealed religion. That it has no parallel in the history of prejudice. That it has been at the core of Christian civilization for two millennia. That, inscribed in the Quran, it is the constituent feature of Arab and Islamic civilizations. Anti-Semitism, moreover, has had its reach vastly expanded by the new, anti-Israel, form it has taken--as well as by the fact that Jew-hating populaces have been migrating around the world, specifically from Arab and Islamic countries to Europe and elsewhere....
If the book delivered on its claims, it would be most welcome. But this is a bad book. It lacks balance and originality. It misrepresents or misreads several readily available texts. It is radically under-researched--the brief endnotes comprising mostly Web references to news items. (For example, though he criticizes Stéphane Hessel's 2010 book, "Time for Outrage!," the relevant endnote cites not the book itself but a New York Times story about it.) It is characterized throughout by overstatement and contains some truly ludicrous judgments. (John Chrysostom wasn't "the most significant theologian of the Catholic Church after Christianity became the religion of the Roman Empire.") Its tone is querulous, hectoring and self-important. (Apparently, we needed Mr. Goldhagen to point out the significance of English as a world language, a feature of the global era hitherto, he says, "virtually uncommented-upon.")....
I have written this review with reluctance. That there should be strife within the party to which Mr. Goldhagen and I both belong, the party of anti-anti-Semites, will only give satisfaction to the haters. But we must be the smart, truth-telling participants in this terrible struggle; we must be intelligent in our judgments, reliable in the claims we make. And for sure, while we must not minimize dangers, we shouldn't overstate them either. "The Devil That Never Dies" doesn't contribute to our existing understanding of anti-Semitism; it doesn't give anti-anti-Semites fresh, good arguments. Indeed, it is so easily and justly dismissible, it weakens the very cause its author seeks to promote.
Interview with the author- Daniel-Goldhagen
Related - Makow The Riddle of Anti Semitism
--------- Cabala - How Sex Became Our Religion
---------- Confessions of an Ex Luciferian Jew
---------- Blodgett: Why do People Hate Jews?
Michael Hoffman writes:
On p. 100 Mr. Goldhagen writes, "The Jewish religion, as epitomized by the demonized text the Talmud and its alleged teachings..."
That's virtually all he has to say in his volume of 485 pages concerning Orthdodox Judaism's holiest book and the fount of its halacha.
Goldhagen is so sloppy he doesn't even distinguish between the Talmud Bavli and the Talmud Yerushalmi (the former is authoritiative, the latter is not). Nor does he dare to expound on the "alleged teachings" of the "Talmud" that have caused it to be "demonized."
This claim presents a logical challenge: how does one demonize a book that itself demonizes the New Testament, Jesus Christ, His Mother Mary and goyim in general?
Can one accurately say that Goldhagen has "demonized" "Mein Kampf"?
How does one go about demonizing the Talmud Bavli, a book of pronographic lies, group defamation and advocacy of theft, murder and deceit?
The Babylonian ("Bavli") Talmud is the source of much of the informed protest against Orthodox rabbinic dogma, from eminent authorities such as Dr. Alexander McCaul of King's College London. Goldhagen prefers to discuss at length the cartoonish "Protocols of Zion," whose provenance is highly questionable, rather than explain to his readers how the documented bigotry, racism and self-worship in the Talmud Bavli came to be enshrined as the basis of Pharisaic (i.e. Mishnaic) post-Temple Judaism and its derivatives: the Gemara, Mishneh Torah, Shulchan Aruch, Mishnah Berurah, etc.
On p. 29 Goldhagen makes risible comparisons between the lurid, probably faked "Protocols" and the well-researched writing of two eminent critics of Israeli colonialism, Professors Mearsheimer and Walt, terming their book on the Israeli lobby "an update on the notorious antisemitic tract The Protocols of the Elders of Zion." Outlandish, purple prose like the preceding has been a hallmark of fanatical partisans of the dispossession and extrusion of the Palestinians for decades, among whom we number Mr. Goldhagen.
"The Devil that Never Dies" is so embarrassing that even a charter member of the Zionist thought police, Anthony Julius, has termed it, "truly ludicrous." Julius documents Goldhagen's intellectual dishonesty in the Sept. 13, 2013 edition of the Wall Strret Journal, p. A13.
Goldhagen is unconscious of the fact that the devil that never dies is the self regard and egoism of human beings organized within creeds of extreme nationalist chauvinism, whether they be Nazism, Salafist Islam or Talmudic Judaism.
Makow challenges Hoffman:
"Goldhagen prefers to discuss at length the cartoonish "Protocols of Zion," whose provenance is highly questionable, " you write.
And " Goldhagen makes risible comparisons between the lurid, probably faked "Protocols"
Protocols Forgery Claim Flawed http://www.
"I have never seen primary documentation authenticating the Protocols, so one can argue pro or contra for decades.
But you miss the point: the Protocols is where the rabbis and Zionists want the focus to remain.
They want to deflect debate and attention away from the documented and indefensible Talmud Bavli.
It's a blunder to fall into their trap."
It isn't either-or. They are perfectly consistent.
For me, the authenticity of the Protocols is self evident."
"For me, the authenticity of the Protocols is self evident."
"As a historian I can't accept that notion as evidence.
Moreover it is being used to distract from the Talmud and make the disputed Protocols the heart of the controversy as a function of the revival of 1930s-style opposition to Judaism.
We need 21st century tactics."
"As a historian do you actually think the Masonic Jews would acknowledge the Protocols are authentic any more than they admit the true nature of the Talmud? Isn't it enough that the world is actually unfolding according to this blueprint?"
What kind of historian can't recognize the truth when it is self-evident?
It is disconcerting that their Master Plan has been public knowledge for more than 100 years and even some of their most brilliant and courageous opponents don't get it.